Court of Appeal, Accra | [1999–2000] 2 GLR 807 | Judgment delivered on 2 March 2000
Coram: Brobbey, Afreh and Ansah JJA
Introduction:
Where an employer has the option to give employees notice of redundancy or pay them in lieu of notice, should the payment reflect salary increases which take effect during the period that the notice would have covered?
This case examined the proper calculation of redundancy benefits, the effect of a collective agreement on employees’ rights, and the obligation of an employer to act fairly when exercising a contractual discretion affecting employees’ remuneration.
Facts:
The Appellants were employees of Volta Aluminium Company Ltd (VALCO) until 16th May 1994, when they were declared redundant. Their employment was governed by a Labour Agreement between VALCO and the Industrial and Commercial Workers’ Union (ICU).
Article 15(e) of the Labour Agreement provided that employees declared redundant would be given two months’ notice or paid in lieu of notice. VALCO elected to terminate the Appellants’ employment immediately and paid them two months’ salary in lieu, calculated on their salaries as at 16 May 1994.
At the time of the redundancy, however, a wage review contemplated under the Labour Agreement was approaching. The wage re-opening subsequently commenced on 1st July 1994 and resulted in a 71.25% increase in employees’ earnings. This increase took effect before the two-month notice period would have expired in July 1994.
The Appellants contended that their terminal benefits ought to have been calculated on the remuneration that would have accrued to them by the end of the two-month notice period, rather than their salaries as at the date of termination.
The High Court dismissed their action, holding that VALCO was entitled to calculate their benefits using the salaries prevailing when their employment was terminated. Dissatisfied, the employees appealed to the Court of Appeal.
Issues for Determination:
The Court’s Holding:
The Court of Appeal, by majority, found that:
v. Accordingly, the appeal was allowed by a majority of Brobbey and Ansah JJA, with Afreh JA dissenting. Ansah JA expressly agreed with Brobbey JA’s reasons and conclusions and concurred in allowing the appeal.
The Appellants were entitled to the difference between what had already been paid to them and the amount due upon application of the wage increase, subject to deduction of the goodwill payment already received. Interest was also awarded.
Implication of the Decision:
The decision establishes that where an employee is entitled to payment in lieu of notice, the calculation may not necessarily be confined to the employee’s salary on the date employment is terminated. Where the governing agreement provides for the remuneration that would have accrued during the notice period, benefits becoming payable within that period must be taken into account.
The case also affirms the importance of collective agreements in protecting employees. Rights conferred under a collective agreement cannot simply be negotiated away to the employees’ disadvantage where the governing legislation makes those rights non-waivable.
Importantly, the decision does not establish that every subsequent salary increase must be retrospectively applied to a redundant employee. Brobbey JA expressly emphasised the peculiar facts of the case: the wage increase arose within the very period covered by the payment in lieu of notice. The principle did not extend to benefits dependent upon an employer’s discretion or other conditions.
Significant Quote:
“No court of equity and conscience should allow or even encourage employers, using a declaration of redundancy, to benefit from its employees by depriving them of what they would have earned or would have been entitled to.”
– Brobbey JA
Commentary and Insight:
This case highlights that an employer’s contractual discretion must be exercised consistently with the terms and protections contained in the governing employment agreement. The fact that an employer may choose between giving notice and paying in lieu does not necessarily mean that the choice may be exercised in a manner that deprives employees of remuneration which the agreement entitles them to receive during the notice period.
The case is particularly significant for employees covered by collective agreements. While trade unions ordinarily negotiate on behalf of their members, the Court recognised that statutory protection of rights contained in a collective agreement places a limit on what may subsequently be surrendered through negotiations.
For employers and employees alike, the decision demonstrates that payment in lieu of notice is not merely about the date on which the employment relationship ends; its proper calculation depends upon the language of the agreement governing what the employee would have earned during the relevant notice period.
The courtroom is often described as the temple of justice, one which is open to…
The Court has delivered its ruling on the submission of no case to answer in…
The law, as a discipline, is deeply concerned with accountability. Thus, whenever a document is…
He urged the newly enrolled lawyers to cultivate habits of thorough preparation particularly in the…
As Washington takes a more disruptive, transactional, and uncharacteristically unconventional approach to global cooperation, and…
During moments when staff of the judicial service embark on strike action to demand their…